close

Alkan, Charles-Valentin : 48 Motifs Op.63

Work Overview

Music ID : 651
Publication Year:1861
First Publisher:S.Richault
Dedicated to:Madmoiselle La princesse Louise de Schleswig-Holstein
Instrumentation:Piano Solo 
Genre:pieces
Total Playing Time:1 hr 20 min 00 sec
Copyright:Public Domain

Commentary (4)

Author : Ueda, Yasushi

Last Updated: January 1, 2010
[Open]
Note: This article is automatically translated from the original Japanese text. The author of the original work did not supervise this translation.

Publication: Paris, Simon Richault, 1861

Dedication: Mademoiselle La Princesse Louise de Schleswig-Holstein

This collection is known as "Esquisses" (Sketches), but the first edition bore only the title "48 Motifs." It comprises four volumes, containing 48 pieces that cover all keys, plus an additional 49th piece, "Laus Deo." The detailed process of its composition is unknown, but an alternative version of No. 29 from 1847 has been confirmed, suggesting that Alkan revised and compiled works accumulated from at least 1847 onwards for publication. It condenses the essential characteristics of Alkan as a composer, including satire, humor, longing for the classics, and religious themes.

Around 1860, Alkan had largely ceased social interaction, except with a few close friends like Ferdinand Hiller. His enthusiasm for public concert activities declined, and he spent his time as a keen observer of the Parisian music scene. Meanwhile, the majority of his creative energy was devoted to composition and arrangement. The 48 Motifs, Op. 63, was published in the early 1860s, concurrently with his extensive and meticulous arrangements of Beethoven and Mozart works, accompanied by original cadenzas.

Each book arranges keys systematically, imparting order to the overall tonal palette of the collection. As can be seen from the list of pieces, the keys of the pieces in Book 1 and Book 2 alternate in a sequence of perfect fourths and major sixths. Furthermore, Book 1 proceeds in a major, minor... sequence (C major - F minor - D major - G minor...), while Book 2 follows the reverse order (C minor - F major - D minor - G major...). On the other hand, the keys of the pieces in Book 3 and Book 4 are structured by a cycle of perfect fifths, with major and minor keys alternating. Book 3 begins with a major key (C major - G major - D major...), and Book 4 begins with a minor key (C minor - G major - D minor...). In this way, the pairs of Book 1 and Book 2, and Book 3 and Book 4, are structured to juxtapose yin and yang, much like the negative-positive relationship in photography. Such elaborate and unique key design reflects Alkan's pedantic mode of thought and brings a certain unity to the 48 pieces of diverse character.

Despite being a progressive composer and pianist, Alkan was a staunch traditionalist. Many of the pieces in this work are given suggestive titles reminiscent of Couperin, Rameau, Scarlatti, and Mozart. Given that he performed works by Couperin, Rameau, Scarlatti, J.S. Bach, and his sons in concerts, it is clear that his traditionalist aspect held significant meaning not only in his arrangements but also in his original compositions. However, traditionally rooted musical styles are often parodied, and the harmonic language and pianism are imbued with an avant-garde spirit.

Book 1

  • No. 1: C major, Assez lentement "La vision"
  • No. 2: F minor, Allegro "Le staccatissimo"
  • No. 3: D major, Andantino "Le legatissimo"
  • No. 4: G minor, Allegretto "Les cloches"
  • "Cloches" (French) refers to church or monastery bells of various sizes. It was a popular subject for piano pieces in the 19th century. Alkan's realistic depiction, with the repetition of identical patterns and the striking and decay of sounds, is rarely seen in other composers of his time. The bell strokes should be strong and uniform, and all repeated patterns should be played regularly, like a bell swinging at a constant speed. A similar technique can already be seen in his Marche funèbre, Op. 26 (1846).
  • No. 5: E minor, Quasi coro "Les initiés"
  • No. 6: A minor, Allegro moderato "Fuguetta"
  • No. 7: F-sharp major, Andantino "Le frisson"
  • No. 8: B minor, "Pseudo-naïveté"
  • No. 9: A-flat major, Andante "Confidence"
  • No. 10: C-sharp minor, Allegro vivace "Increpatio"
  • No. 11: B-flat major, Assez lentement "Les soupirs"
  • No. 12: E-flat minor, Lentement "Barcarollette"

Book 2

  • No. 13: C minor, Andante flebile "Ressouvenir"
  • No. 14: F major, Vivamente "Duettino"
  • No. 15: D minor, Tempo giusto "Tutti de concerto dans le genre ancien"
  • No. 16: G major, Assez vite "Fantaisie"
  • No. 17: E minor, Allegretto "Petit prélude à trois"
  • No. 18: A major, Allegretto "Liedchen"
  • The original title "Liedchen" (German) means "little song." The opening and closing passages, indicated by small notes, are the prelude and postlude to the song, depicting the instrumental part expressed on the piano. Listen carefully to the song in the uppermost voice of the right hand and the counter-melody in the left hand.
  • No. 19: F-sharp minor, Assez lentement "Grâces"
  • No. 20: B major, Allegrettino "Petite marche villageoise"
  • No. 21: G-sharp minor, Assez lentement "Morituri te salutant"
  • No. 22: D-flat major, Assez doucement "Innocenzia"
  • No. 23: B-flat minor, D'un pas ordinaire "L'homme aux sabots"
  • No. 24: E-flat major, Vivement "Contradanse"

Book 3

  • No. 25: C major, Prestissimo "La poursuite"
  • No. 26: G minor, Andante "Petit air. Genre ancien"
  • No. 27: D major, Vivace "Rigaudon"
  • The Rigaudon is a lively duple-meter folk dance popular in England and France in the 17th-18th centuries. A stylized Rigaudon was also danced at the court of Louis XIV, but Alkan satirically depicts the former here.
  • No. 28: A minor, Fort et carrément "Inflexibilité"
  • No. 29: E major, Appassionatissimo "Délire"
  • No. 30: B minor, Allegrettino "Petit air dolent"
  • No. 31: F-sharp major, Vivace "Début de quatuor"
  • No. 32: C-sharp minor, Moderato "Alla 《Vendrai carino》 di Mozart"
  • No. 33: A-flat major, Doucement "《Fais dodo》"
  • A lullaby. The original title "Fais dodo" (pronounced "fay doh-doh" in French) is a soothing phrase used to put children to sleep. Be fully aware of and emphasize the color change brought about by the flatted seventh degree of the scale (G-flat, and D-flat in the middle section in E-flat major).
  • No. 34: E-flat minor, Lento "Odi prefanum vulgus et arceo: favete linguis"
  • No. 35: B-flat major, Tempo ordinario "Musique militaire"
  • No. 36: F minor, Presto "Toccatina"

Book 4

  • No. 37: C minor, Presto "Scherzettino"
  • No. 38: G major, Doucement "Les bons souhaits 《Le ciel vous soit toujours prospère!》"
  • No. 39: D minor, Andantino-mesto "Héraclite et Démocrite"
  • No. 40: A major, Vif et léger "《Attendez-moi sous L'orme》"
  • No. 41: E minor, Moderato "Les enharmoniques"
  • No. 42: B major, Andantino "Petit air à 5 voix"
  • No. 43: F-sharp minor, Andantino "Notturnino-innamorato"
  • No. 44: C-sharp major, Con felicita "Transports"
  • No. 45: G-sharp minor, Lentement "Les diablotins"
  • No. 46: E-flat major, Amorosamemte "Le premier billet doux"
  • A piece with charming psychological depiction. The theme, beginning chromatically and repeatedly ascending and descending in an arc, constantly modulates, delaying the "relief" of the tonic key until the latter half. Here, too, be fully aware of the counter-melody integrated into the left-hand accompaniment part.
  • No. 47: B-flat minor, Presto "Scherzetto"
  • No. 48: F major, Lento "En songe"
  • The final piece of the 48 Motifs. Pay attention to the instruction to press both the damper pedal and the soft pedal simultaneously. Although there are no further pedal change instructions until the final measure, to avoid excessive mixing of sounds, it would be advisable on a modern piano to skillfully create a hazy effect by adjusting the damper pedal's depth. The piece concludes with a sudden awakening and silence.
  • Unnumbered: C major, Assez lentement "Laus Deo"
  • The Latin title means "Praise be to God." The theme, forming the intervals C-D-F-E, is found in J. J. Fux's (1660–1741) counterpoint treatise Gradus ad Parnassum, and many composers, including Bach, Mozart, and Beethoven, used this theme in their compositions. Alkan, who was well-versed in strict counterpoint, also used this theme as the fugato subject in the second movement of his Grande Sonate, Op. 33. Regarding this theme in the sonata, its congruence with the hymn for the Feast of Corpus Christi, Verbum supernum, has also been noted. In this work with a Latin title, Alkan (though Jewish) seems to have embraced Catholic subject matter from an artistic perspective, elevating it to a declaration of faith in art.
Writer: Ueda, Yasushi

Author : Murai, Yukiro

Last Updated: March 12, 2015
[Open]
Note: This article is automatically translated from the original Japanese text. The author of the original work did not supervise this translation.

Note: This entry is currently being revised. The content may change in the future. (November 27, 2015, Editorial Department)

"If I had to live my life over again, I would want to set the entire Bible to music, from the first word to the last."

48 Motifs, Op. 63, was published by Richault et Cie six months after Alkan wrote this to his friend F. Hiller. However, Alkan's correspondence from that period, while speaking concretely about other works he was likely preparing in parallel, does not reveal Alkan's inner thoughts during the composition of 48 Motifs. Amidst this, one possibility emerges: 48 Motifs bears a striking resemblance to 25 Préludes dans les tons majeurs et mineurs, Op. 31, a collection of pieces Alkan published 14 years earlier, in 1847. Could Alkan have kept 25 Préludes in mind as a precursor to 48 Motifs?

Indeed, a comparison of the two collections reveals that in 25 Préludes, movements 1-24, and in 48 Motifs, movements 1-48, cycle through all major and minor keys (hereinafter referred to as the "full major-minor cycle section"). Subsequently, the former is accompanied by a religious concluding movement titled "Prière" (Prayer), and the latter by "Laus Deo" (Praise be to God), both religious finales. While the pieces in the full major-minor cycle section are both approximately 1-3 minutes long, the concluding movements are both around 5 minutes, a clear correspondence.

So, what significance did 25 Préludes hold for Alkan? David Conway, an expert on the relationship between Judaism and music, states in his book Jewry in Music that 25 Préludes is a groundbreaking example of incorporating Jewish melodies and other elements into so-called art music. Indeed, the full major-minor cycle section of 25 Préludes includes:

  • citations of synagogue melodies
  • numerological references to morning prayers (Shacharit) and evening prayers (Ma'ariv) and the Song of Songs from the Old Testament
  • paraphrases of Psalm 150
  • klezmer dance idioms

The way these elements converge in the concluding movement "Prière" seems to reflect the significant presence of Jewish elements in Alkan's compositions. However, contemporary critical reviews did not shed much light on the Jewish elements in 25 Préludes. The music theorist Fétis, who would later form a strong bond of trust with Alkan, published a favorable review of 25 Préludes in the July 25, 1847 issue of the music magazine Revue et Gazette musicale de Paris, but he barely touched upon the Jewish elements contained therein. Furthermore, turning to the German-speaking world, an anonymous review in the March 25, 1848 issue of Neue Zeitschrift für Musik merely elaborated at length on the fact that 25 Préludes could be performed not only on piano but also on organ. Thus, given a situation where various Jewish elements were embedded in 25 Préludes but not necessarily welcomed, is it not possible that 48 Motifs, which Alkan undertook based on a similar concept, entrusts these Jewish elements in a more refined form? We will continue to discuss this point in the section on musical analysis.

Writer: Murai, Yukiro

Author : Murai, Yukiro

Last Updated: March 12, 2015
[Open]
Note: This article is automatically translated from the original Japanese text. The author of the original work did not supervise this translation.

※This entry is currently being revised. Please note that the content may change in the future. (November 27, 2015, Editorial Department)

The Peculiar Key Arrangement

What particularly draws attention in 48 Motifs while simultaneously shrouding the entire collection in a mysterious veil is undoubtedly its peculiar key arrangement. In collections that cycle through all keys, several typical patterns of key arrangement exist: the chromatic type seen in Bach's The Well-Tempered Clavier, the circle of fifths type seen in Chopin's Preludes, or the increasing black key type often found in keyboard exercise collections by composers like Hanon. However, the key arrangement of 48 Motifs does not conform to any of these. We strongly encourage the reader to consult the general overview section to examine this arrangement.

The Iconographic Program: The Star of David

What did Alkan intend with this unique arrangement? It becomes evident when the arrangement, divided into Volumes 1 through 4, is plotted on the circle of fifths. The trajectory of the plot in Volumes 1 and 3 reveals the image of the Star of David, a Jewish symbol (see Figure 1).

Figure 1: When the keys of the pieces in Volume 1 of Alkan's 48 Motifs are plotted on the circle of fifths, the image of the Star of David, a Jewish symbol, is depicted.

Connection to "Laus Deo" and 17th-Century Treatises

These Stars of David form an iconographic program that converges towards the final piece, 'Laus Deo' (Praise be to God). The Jewish elements, which were openly revealed in 25 Preludes but not generally well-received, were entrusted once again to 48 Motifs, albeit in a transformed and concealed manner.

The iconographic program of 48 Motifs actually bears a striking resemblance to those found in music theory treatises from around the 17th century. At that time, many treatises presented diagrams in the main text where music theory was closely integrated with religion or philosophy, and concluded with the phrase 'Laus Deo' (Praise be to God) on the final page (see Figure 2).

Figure 2: The left side of the figure shows, as just one example, the iconographic program from El Melopeo y Maestro, a music theory treatise by Cerone, a prominent Italian music theorist of the 16th-17th centuries. It is plausible that the iconographic program of Alkan's 48 Motifs on the right side was conceived with such programs in mind.

48 Motifs as a Music Theory Text

Furthermore, upon re-examining the pieces in the full major and minor key cycle of 48 Motifs, one notices the presence of many terms that could be explained in a music theory treatise, such as 'Staccatissimo,' 'Legatissimo,' and 'Enharmonic.' Moreover, the fact that the majority of the pieces in the full major and minor key cycle are brief and based on a single musical idea is a characteristic consistent with musical examples in theory treatises. It is plausible that Alkan projected the character of a music theory book onto 48 Motifs.

The "48" vs. "49" Discrepancy

This interpretation also explains another peculiar aspect of 48 Motifs: despite containing a total of 49 pieces, including the final 'Laus Deo,' the collection is titled '48 Motifs.' This is not a misprint. Records at the Bibliothèque nationale de France indicate that Alkan himself instructed the publisher Richault to add this. Furthermore, in Richault's catalog of Alkan's works, only 'Laus Deo' is written in italics. This distinction of 'Laus Deo' is also likely modeled after the layout of the final page of music theory treatises. The phrase 'Laus Deo' on the final page of such treatises is often written in a different font or size from the main text (see Figure 2).

Conclusion

Even 48 Motifs, which at first glance appears to be a collection of trivial daily sketches, was entrusted with a grand and profound iconographic program. This collection quietly embodies the philosophical state Alkan reached in the 1860s, within its multilayered structure.

Writer: Murai, Yukiro

Author : Morishita, Yui

Last Updated: March 12, 2018
[Open]
Note: This article is automatically translated from the original Japanese text. The author of the original work did not supervise this translation.

(Editor's Note) From 2008 to 2010, a series of commentary articles and performance audio recordings for all 49 pieces by Yui Morishita was serialized. Please refer to the link.

Collection of Marvelous Short Pieces: Esquisses – An Invitation to the World of Alkan's Piano Works

Writer: Morishita, Yui

Movements (49)

La Vision Op.63-1

Total Performance Time: 3 min 00 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Le Staccatissimo Op.63-2

Total Performance Time: 1 min 00 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Le Legatissimo Op.63-3

Total Performance Time: 1 min 30 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Les Cloches Op.63-4

Key: g-moll  Total Performance Time: 1 min 00 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Les Inities Op.63-5

Total Performance Time: 4 min 30 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Fuguette Op.63-6

Total Performance Time: 1 min 20 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Le Frisson Op.63-7

Total Performance Time: 1 min 50 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Pseudo-Naivete Op.63-8

Total Performance Time: 2 min 30 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Confidence Op.63-9

Total Performance Time: 2 min 00 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Increpatio Op.63-10

Total Performance Time: 1 min 30 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Les Soupirs Op.63-11

Total Performance Time: 2 min 00 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Barcarollette Op.63-12

Total Performance Time: 1 min 30 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Ressouvenir Op.63-13

Total Performance Time: 2 min 30 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Duettino Op.63-14

Total Performance Time: 1 min 50 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Tutti de Concerto dans le genre ancien Op.63-15

Total Performance Time: 1 min 00 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Fantaisie Op.63-16

Total Performance Time: 1 min 20 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Petit Prelude a 3 Op.63-17

Total Performance Time: 0 min 50 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Liedchen Op.63-18

Total Performance Time: 1 min 00 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Graces Op.63-19

Total Performance Time: 2 min 00 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Petite Marche Villageoise Op.63-20

Total Performance Time: 1 min 30 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Morituri te salutant Op.63-21

Total Performance Time: 1 min 30 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Innocenza Op.63-22

Total Performance Time: 1 min 40 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

L'Homme aux Sabot Op.63-23

Total Performance Time: 0 min 30 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Contredanse Op.63-24

Total Performance Time: 1 min 00 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

La Poursuite Op.63-25

Total Performance Time: 0 min 40 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Petit Air Op.63-26

Total Performance Time: 1 min 00 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Rigaudon Op.63-27

Key: D-Dur  Total Performance Time: 0 min 50 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Inflexibilite Op.63-28

Total Performance Time: 1 min 00 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Delire Op.63-29

Total Performance Time: 1 min 00 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Petit Air Dolent Op.63-30

Total Performance Time: 1 min 50 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Debut de Quatuor Op.63-31

Total Performance Time: 1 min 00 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Minuettino Op.63-32

Total Performance Time: 4 min 00 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Fais Dodo Op.63-33

Key: As-Dur  Total Performance Time: 1 min 10 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Odi profanum vulgus et arceo Op.63-34

Total Performance Time: 2 min 40 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Musique Militaire Op.63-35

Total Performance Time: 1 min 10 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Toccatina Op.63-36

Total Performance Time: 1 min 00 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Scherzettino Op.63-37

Total Performance Time: 1 min 00 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Les Bons Souhaits Op.63-38

Total Performance Time: 1 min 40 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Heraclite et Democrite Op.63-39

Total Performance Time: 1 min 50 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Attendez - moi sous l'orme Op.63-40

Total Performance Time: 0 min 40 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Les Enharmoniques Op.63-41

Total Performance Time: 2 min 00 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Petit Air Op.63-42

Total Performance Time: 1 min 10 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Notturnino - Innamorato Op.63-43

Total Performance Time: 2 min 00 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Transports Op.63-44

Total Performance Time: 0 min 40 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Les Diablotins Op.63-45

Total Performance Time: 2 min 40 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Le Premier Billet Doux Op.63-46

Key: Es-Dur  Total Performance Time: 1 min 20 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Scherzetto Op.63-47

Total Performance Time: 2 min 00 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

En Songe Op.63-48

Key: F-Dur  Total Performance Time: 1 min 30 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Laus Deo Op.63-49

Key: C-Dur  Total Performance Time: 4 min 40 sec 

Explanation 0

Sheet Music 0

Arrangement 0

Sheet Music

Scores List (3)