Heller, Stephen : 25 études mélodiques Op.45
Work Overview
First Publisher:Grus
Instrumentation:Piano Solo
Genre:etude
Total Playing Time:40 min 20 sec
Copyright:Public Domain
Commentary (3)
Author : Ueda, Yasushi
Last Updated: July 7, 2011
[Open]
Author : Ueda, Yasushi
1. Background of the Work's Composition
This work was published in 1844 in the cities of Paris, Lyon, Berlin, and Milan, as a preliminary collection of etudes to be undertaken before performing 24 Etudes in All Major and Minor Keys, Op. 16 (Paris, M. Schlesinger, 1840, reissued the following year as The Art of Phrasing).
Although this collection is still known today under titles such as Melodious Etudes, the title of the first edition was simply 25 Etudes, followed by a series of explanations: "to serve as an introduction to The Art of Phrasing, and as preparation for etudes and various works of the modern school."
The year before publishing this work, in 1843, Heller wrote in a letter to Jenny Montgolfier, an influential pianist and teacher in Lyon, "Could you send this letter to [the Lyon publisher] Bunel? I am asking him for a little work, to recover from the 'Etudes' (with which I am satisfied), and... to earn some money" (Cf. J.-J. Eigeldinger p.117).
Etudes, with their educational and practical aspects, were indeed a genre that brought considerable profit to composers. The following year, Heller wrote again in a letter to Montgolfier: "Bunel is supposed to send me 500 francs for the two works I am about to write. Thanks to this, I am promised an easy journey. As soon as I receive the money, I will depart and we will meet soon." (Cf. J.-J. Eigeldinger pp.135-136) These "two works" are thought to be 30 Progressive Etudes, Op. 46, and 25 Etudes for the Development of Rhythm and Expression, Op. 47 (both published in 1849), which were published after Op. 45. From this background, it can be inferred that he intensively wrote etudes during this period to secure funds for activities such as concert tours. From the perspective of etude composition, although each piece adheres to the traditional framework since Clementi (for example, No. 7 is an exercise in finger independence similar to the first piece of Gradus ad Parnassum), each piece, though short, possesses a unique character and is written with extreme delicacy and meticulousness. Each piece is short, and the score may appear simple at first glance, but performance requires a great deal of attention. This point was stated by the composer himself in the preface to a new edition published by Lemoine during Heller's lifetime (although this is a reprint of the preface affixed to the first edition of Op. 47). The preface to the Lemoine edition is quoted below:
There exist countless collections of etudes whose sole purpose is to train the mechanism of the fingers. I, however, set a completely different goal while writing this series of characteristic short pieces.
I wished for students to perform the pieces expressively, gracefully, elegantly, and energetically, in accordance with the specific character of each work. I wished to awaken in them a sense of musical rhythm and to guide them towards the most accurate and perfect reproduction of the composer's intentions.
To achieve my goal, I ask teachers to ensure that their students perform each of these 25 etudes carefully, with all nuances, delicately, and with the appropriate emotion for each piece.
The four collections of etudes mentioned above, published in the 1840s, continued to be published even after Heller's death, and particularly for the pieces in Op. 45, descriptive titles, likely unrelated to Heller himself, were added by various publishers and became widely disseminated. At least, no titles for individual pieces can be found in the collections published in Paris during Heller's lifetime.
Author : Sezaki, Junko
Last Updated: July 7, 2011
[Open]
Author : Sezaki, Junko
3. On the Titles
As mentioned earlier, this collection of pieces was published at some point with titles likely unrelated to the composer. While these titles, imbued with various characteristics evoking nature and seasons, help learners form concrete images and foster familiarity with the works, titles such as No. 3 "Serious Study" and No. 12 "Strict" could, on the contrary, give learners a negative impression. When engaging with these titles, one should always bear in mind that while Heller was inspired by literary subjects, he did not prefer to bestow facile descriptive titles upon his own works.
Author : Hayashikawa, Takashi
Last Updated: July 7, 2011
[Open]
Author : Hayashikawa, Takashi
2. On the Editions
The first edition, published in Paris where Heller was active, appeared around 1844 from Grus under the title 25 Études. In the first edition, No. 11 was in 4/4 time, marked Allegro vivace, whereas the current editions feature an entirely different piece in 3/4 time, marked Allegro (both in F major).
Paris First Edition (Grus, 1844), No. 11
Current Edition (G. Schirmer, n.d. etc.), No. 11
Furthermore, No. 17 in the first edition was not in the ternary form (main section – middle section – main section) found in current editions; instead, the main section was to be played twice in its entirety (a repeat sign was indicated at the end of the score).
This collection was later published by Lemoine in an edition correcting misprints (though some misprints remained uncorrected even in the Lemoine edition). It is likely that No. 11 was replaced with the current piece at this stage. While the current No. 11 adopts a structure of introduction – main section – middle section – main section, the Lemoine edition concludes with introduction – main section, showing a difference in the ending. The reason for this piece's replacement is not clear, but it might be because the opening of the first edition's No. 11 bore too strong a resemblance to the opening of Schumann's Carnaval, Op. 9 (or perhaps its rhythm recalled the finale of Schumann's Symphonic Etudes, Op. 13).
R. Schumann, Carnaval, Op. 9 (1837), opening
Furthermore, at an unknown date, a score was published by Schlesinger in Berlin, retitled 25 Études mélodiques and marked “Nouvelle Édition révue par l’auteur” (New Edition revised by the composer). At this stage, a middle section was added to No. 11 and No. 17, and consequently, the main sections also underwent some minor revisions. This Schlesinger edition is likely considered the definitive version, and most subsequent editions of this etude collection published worldwide are based on this Schlesinger version.
In Japan, an edition was published by Zen-On in 1965, with each piece accompanied by a subtitle, presumably based on the edition from G. Schirmer in the United States. In the Zen-On edition, the editor states in the preface that it is “very useful for mastering the use of the pedal,” and the score includes elaborate pedaling instructions. However, in the three aforementioned editions Heller was involved in publishing, pedal indications are only sparingly noted. Furthermore, although the reason is not stated, the Zen-On edition contains almost no slurs, and regarding dynamic markings, there are numerous instances where they differ in direction from all other editions (at least those the author could consult). For example, in No. 2, measures 83-85, other editions crescendo and end the phrase forte, whereas the Zen-On edition diminuendos and ritardandos, ending the phrase piano. Further detailed investigation into the subtle differences among the various editions is awaited.
Movements (25)
No.5 Allegretto comodo Op.45-5
Total Performance Time: 1 min 50 sec
No.9 Andante quasi Allegretto Op.45-9
Total Performance Time: 2 min 20 sec
No. 13 Allegro scherzando Op.45-13
Total Performance Time: 1 min 10 sec
No. 16 Andatino con tenerezza Op.45-16
Total Performance Time: 2 min 20 sec
No. 17 Allegro vivace Op.45-17
Total Performance Time: 2 min 20 sec
No.19 Allegretto grazioso Op.45-19
Total Performance Time: 1 min 10 sec
No.22 Allegretto con moto Op.45-22
Total Performance Time: 2 min 10 sec
No.23 Allegro di molto Op.45-23
Total Performance Time: 1 min 10 sec
No. 24 Allegro veloce Op.45-24
Total Performance Time: 1 min 10 sec
No.25 Allegro con brio Op.45-25
Total Performance Time: 2 min 30 sec
PTNA & Partner Channel Videos(28items) View More
Reference Videos & Audition Selections(12items)
Sheet Music
Scores List (8)

(株)エー・ティ・エヌ

(株)エー・ティ・エヌ

(株)エー・ティ・エヌ

(株)全音楽譜出版社

(株)全音楽譜出版社

(株)学研プラス

(株)全音楽譜出版社

Musikverlag Doblinger