close

Lyadov, Anatoly Konstantinovich : 4 Preludes Andante H-Dur Op.39-3

Work Overview

Music ID : 23601
Instrumentation:Piano Solo 
Genre:prelude
Total Playing Time:1 min 30 sec
Copyright:Public Domain

Commentary (1)

Author : Ooi, Kazurou

Last Updated: November 23, 2022
[Open]
Note: This article is automatically translated from the original Japanese text. The author of the original work did not supervise this translation.

The most perplexing issue with this prelude is the tempo. The composer's score indicates Andante, eighth note = 58. When actually played at eighth note = 58, it becomes clear that it is quite slow. However, since the time signature is 6/8, it is a compound duple meter.

Indeed, the tempos in performance videos vary greatly, with some videos featuring considerably faster tempos. There were extreme differences among pianists, such as eighth note = 150, eighth note = 100, and eighth note = 50. It was also conceivable that the eighth note notation might have been mistaken for a dotted quarter note (including printing errors, editing errors, or misreadings by the pianist).

However, if this piece is played too fast, the modulations in the middle section (from measure 9 onwards) become too abrupt and intense, which also sounds unnatural. On the other hand, if played strictly at the prescribed eighth note = 58, the tempo is so slow that one might feel it should be explicitly marked Adagio, even to the extent of questioning the necessity of a compound meter.

In my personal opinion, I believe eighth note = 100 would be just right. Furthermore, as the piece progresses, there are passages with ornaments and triplets that require more time. Therefore, instead of maintaining a strict metronomic tempo throughout, it is advisable to take time flexibly, naturally, and freely.

Writer: Ooi, Kazurou
No videos available currently.  

Sheet Music

Scores List (0)

No scores registered.